Mysterious American kidnap and release in southern Philippines, Part 2

American Milton Taylor in captivity

Two days after the release of American Milton Taylor, we can establish some facts:

1. He was kidnapped in January in Cagayan de Oro City.
2. He was released on Wednesday, April 13.
3. At least one Lanao del Sur official paid P100,000 for his release, according to Cagayan de Oro City Mayor Vicente Emano.
4. At least one official report links his kidnappers to the MILF’s 102nd Base Command.

According to an official report, Milton Taylor checked into Lamar Inn in Cagayan de Oro City as “Sam Taylor” in December 2010. He disappeared on January 11, 2011. Four days later, hotel staff did an inventory of his belongings in room 604. On January 19, the hotel’s credit department reported him to the police for not paying bills amounting to about P30,000.

Four days later on January 22, sources tell me a woman contacted the US embassy to tell officials that Taylor was missing. Col. Leo Ferrer of the Army’s 601st Infantry Brigade said the US embassy reported that to the Philippines in January as well. At least one official report called Taylor “a known treasure hunter” and one concluded “that said foreign national was evading from his accountability of the said hotel.”

Ransom Demands
Military and police intelligence sources tell me that on February 11, Taylor allegedly called a friend and demanded Php 10 million in ransom (about USD 230,000) for his kidnappers. This was confirmed by Senior Superintendent Antonio Montalba, deputy police director of the Cagayan de Oro Police, to the Gold Star Daily.

Later on February 11, intelligence sources say his cell phone was used by his kidnappers, who demanded ransom and threatened to kill him if they didn’t get the money.

A little more than a week later, authorities received two videos of Taylor reading a ransom demand. The one I posted yesterday (a close-up) started with the date – January 29. This video, a long-shot, has no date.

The initial demand for Php 10 million was gradually reduced to Php 300,000 before settling at Php 100,000, says Mayor Emano, “for board and lodging.” He said the US embassy refused to pay any money because of its government’s no-ransom policy.

On Wednesday, April 13, Philippine government officials as well as officers of the police and military confirmed Taylor had been kidnapped.

After his release, Taylor told reporters two people approached him at a food stall in Divisoria, Cagayan de Oro City. “They brought me to Iligan City and from there, we transferred to another vehicle, and they blindfolded me. It was a scary experience,” he said.

The Kidnappers
Although there have been no official statements on the kidnappers, a classified intelligence report states: “the perpetrators are followers of CMDR MERCURY and CMDR SANTIAGO, both belonging to the Moro Islamic Liberation Front’s (MILF) 102nd Base Command.”

Again, this is where it gets interesting. The 102nd Base Command operates in Lanao del Sur and Marawi City. Taylor was released Wednesday afternoon at the boundary of Piagapo in Lanao del Sur and Marawi City. Chief Supt Bienvenido Latag said police and military operatives nearly cornered the kidnappers.

The 102nd Base Command is led by Abdulrahman Macapaar alias Commander Bravo. In 2008, Bravo was one of three “renegade” MILF commanders charged by the government for attacks and civilian deaths in four towns in Lanao del Norte. The government offered Php 10 million for him. MILF’s chief negotiator Mohagher Iqbal said then the MILF would investigate the three but would not surrender them to the government.

Kidnap for ransom is a familiar money-making venture for the Abu Sayyaf. Are “renegade” groups of the MILF now using the same tactics?

Wild Card
Having documented all this, let me leave you with a loose end I still have to tie: credible sources within the international intelligence community still have not completely ruled out a “kidnap me” scenario.

Have a good weekend everyone!

This entry was posted in Politics, Terrorism and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Mysterious American kidnap and release in southern Philippines, Part 2

  1. Pingback: More on the mysterious ‘kidnap & release’ of an American in southern Philippines | Newsbreak | Independent Journalism

  2. rachamim ben ami says:

    First, to the poster who asked why an American would be kidnapped. Your first mistake is thinking that the Philippine Government pays ransoms for its kidnapped citizens. It certainly does no such thing. When you see Filipinos released it is always because their family and/or friends have gotten the money themselves. In fact, most never notify the government when a loved one is snatched. The government hurts more than it helps and quite often it is local officials themselves who are behind the kidnappings.

    Has anyone refused to pay? The last refusal was in November in the case of Babette Gomonit. She and her 10 year old grandsom Ceekim were kidnapped from their Pagadian City home in Zamboanga. Her son, Ceekim’s father, tried playing hardball, refused to even discuss the ransome issue.

    At the end of November the sun got an SMS (text) telling him where to dig up his mother’s body, in Sultan Naga Dimaporo, across the provincial border un Lanao del Norte. Still the man refused to pay, saying his mother would want it that way. In March though Ceekim’s mother managed to pay the boy’s ransom on her own and he was released in Cotabato City.

    It happens 3 or 4 times each year as a lesson to others. Most pay, after bargaining to get a much lower price.

    For those thinking the American wasn’t really kidnapped, the man left his passport in his room. Foreigners can’t get a ferry or plane off of Mindanao without their passport. The idea that he ran to avoid paying his bill is ridiculous. While 29,100 Pesos is A LOT to Pinoy it is a week’s wages for most Americans. His wife is in the US and could have easily wired whatever is needed. He wouldn’t leave that passport.

    I find it disgusting that CDO’s PNP Director, Sr.Supt.Antonio Montalba would make such accusations to the press. Holding the man’s passport in his hand he made that vile insult instead of doing his job and actually investigate. No wonder Mayor Emano wants him gone.

  3. Jerry Lynch says:

    "Something is rotten in the state of Denmark" Marcellus in Shakespeare's HAMLET…Something smells rotten in this 'kidnapping" as well.

  4. Ria Roxas says:

    Who is Milton/Sam that the Abu or Milf want to kidnap him? Why him? If US embassy has policy of not paying ransom for it's own citizen, how come the Phil had to pay the burden? Why didn't his family pay for it? What is kidnap me? a fake kidnap? Or he's part of the bandit group and he gets a percentage of ransom money?

  5. quicksilver says:

    Thanks for the update! P10million to P100K? That's a big jump, huh?This is why the MILF confuses me. If you're a "renegade" member of an organization, can that not be considered a defection, and therefore you are no longer a member?It puzzles me, because they're saying that the MILF (the non-renegade version) would "investigate but not surrender them to the government". How can the MILF claim to be a "peaceful" group, when they tolerate members who harm other people? All these being said, the part of me that watches too many crime shows still entertains the idea that really, there were no kidnappers, that the video was self- taped using a camera on a tripod, and we're all up for a big "I knew it!" moment (You know, that moment in the show when the real motive is revealed?). But Mr. Taylor, if you really were kidnapped, I'm sorry I doubted you. I'm glad you're safe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *